Myths: You Can’t Practice Penalties

9 06 2010

Just heard it again. Peter Beardsley this time…

”You can’t practice penalties”.

You just cannot replicate the pressure you see. So there’s no point practising. Bizarre. Only in the surreal world of professional football could such a thinking become accepted wisdom. I seriously doubt David Cameron would have had much success explaining in the Prime Ministerial debates that there was no point in him preparing for office since he could not possibly recreate the pressures he would be under.

Nor is it as we often get told ”a lottery”. For the rest of the world, the golfer Gary Player’s famous oft-repeated quote that ”the more I practice the luckier I get” is one of life’s great truisms. A point so brilliant, so succinctly obvious that it trumps many arguments on the subject of luck. Not in the world of football. In football, penalties – kicking a ball past a goalkeeper into a net – are treated with dubious scepticism.. almost as though there is a longing for better days when such things will be decided by fairer means, such as a coin toss perhaps?

In 1998, such was Glenn Hoddle’s fascination with the psychological, he had the England players practice their penalties from further away than 12 yards. His logic was this – when it came to the big day the players would feel fantastic because the goal would seem closer than they were used to and the penalty therefore appear easier. Interesting then, that Paul Ince and David Batty should strike crisp penalties a little too close to the keeper. Penalties that may well have found the corner if they had been struck from the distance they had been practising them. Muddled thinking?

Call me a radical thinker here, but it occurs to me that of the myriad of possible scenarios a footballer can face on a field, one of the few he stands any chance of exactly recreating in training is the art of a penalty kick. A stationary ball, 12 yards from goal. Practice, practice, practice… and hopefully, as in many walks of life, when the moment comes and the pressure is on, you can fall back on the hours of work you’ve put in and trust that the practice will see you through…  

Or maybe ”you just can’t practice penalties”.




5 responses

10 06 2010
Oli Baker

This is a major gripe of mine. It is drummed into us time and time again that penalties are a ‘lottery’. Surely penalties are a pure examination of technique in a highly pressurised environment?

Predominantly, football is a game of instinct and reaction. As soon as footballers are actually asked to think about what they are doing for a period of longer than a few seconds it comes down to luck whether they succeed or not? Nonsense

10 06 2010
Joshua Askew

Very good article.

The work of Gyuri Vergouw might be interesting to you.

10 06 2010

It’s amazing how little attention is paid to penalties. 1 in 4 knockout games in the WC are decided by penalties, meaning it’s statistically probable you’ll need to win one to win the WC. Keepers are just as obnoxious as the rest though. How many times did keepers dive the wrong way against RvN when he was at United?I think the main thing is that they are simply a test of bottle. How many times have snooker, darts, golf tournaments been lost by epic bottlers? The better players generally handle pressure better but not always eg- Baggio clearly lost it in ’94.

11 06 2010
chris waddle

good point GG. i wish bobby had made me practice abit more back in 1990.

who does GG think should step up to the plate for england when the inevitable shoot out arrives in last 16/ quarter finals?

15 06 2010

haha. well I think Barry, Lampard, Gerrard and Rooney will be on the pitch and take them. Then one or more from Milner, Crouch, Defoe and A.Cole I imagine?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s